The Accused Speaks Out
As stipulated under the "Ordonnance criminelle" of 1670, Angélique was not present to hear the depositions of the witnesses; she was not aware of their accusations against her during their testimonies. As well, the king forbade the presence of lawyers in Nouvelle-France; Angélique had to defend herself, without help, against the public rumour.
During the confrontation process, the king’s prosecutor selected a number of witnesses he wished to confront with the accused in the hope that she would confess her crime. It was at this stage of the trial that Angélique saw the faces of those who had given testimony against her. The court clerk read the depositions in the presence of the witnesses and the accused and then recorded their accusations and denials.
Based on Angélique’s reaction, the prosecutor—not present during the confrontations, but given the transcripts by the judge—submitted new questions to the judge, who once again interrogated the accused, still behind closed doors.
In the sixth week of the trial, a key witness was heard, declaring to have seen the accused set the fire. It was over for Angélique, but she continued to proclaim her innocence.
Court Documents
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Marie dite Manon, slave, with Angélique, May 12, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Re-examination of Ignace Gamelin son, Jeanne Nafrechoux, Marguerite César dit Lagardelette, Charlie dite Charlotte Desrivières, Alexis Lemoine Monière, Jeanne Tailhandier dit Labaume, May 13, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Re-examination of Jacques Jalleteau, Françoise Geoffrion, Marie-Louise Poirier dit Lafleur, Catherine Custeau, Marie-Josèphe Bizet, May 14, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Marguerite César dit Lagardelette with Angélique, May 14, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Fourth interrogation of Angélique, May 14, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Françoise Geoffrion with Angélique, May 14, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Addition of information by Louis Bellefeuille dit Laruine, May 15, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Marie-Louise Poirier dit Lafleur with Angélique, May 15, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Re-examination of Jean-Joseph Boudard dit Laflamandière, May 15, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Re-examination of Louis Langlois dit Traversy and Marie-Françoise Thomelet, May 17, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Louis Langlois dit Traversy with Angélique, May 17, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Marie-Françoise Thomelet with Angélique, May 17, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Request by the judge to the prosecutor, May 17, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Addition of information by Louis Dubuission, May 19, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Addition of information by François Bérey des Essars, May 19, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Public cry summoning Claude Thibault to appear, May 25, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Request by the king’s prosecutor to have the accused subjected to torture, May 26, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Addition of information by Amable Lemoine Monière, May 26, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Charlotte Trottier Desrivières with Angélique, May 27, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Etienne Volant Radisson with Angélique, May 27, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Jean-Joseph Boudard dit Laflamandière with Angélique, May 27, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Re-examination of Amable Lemoine Monière, May 27, 1734
- Juridiction royale de Montréal, Confrontation of Amable Lemoine Monière with Angélique, May 27, 1734